Srpske NovineSrpske Novine

Kosovo Leaders Voice Concern Over Thaci Sentence

After Hashim Thaci was sentenced to 17 months for obstructing justice, Kosovo's president and government say their criticism of the Specialist Chambers stands.

Milan Stanković4 min read0
Podeli
Hashim Thaci in the Kosovo Specialist Chambers courtroom in The Hague at the 17 November verdict
Hashim Thaci in the Specialist Chambers courtroom in The Hague at the verdict that prompted reactions from Kosovo leaders/ Photo: Kosovo Specialist Chambers / BIRN

Kosovo President Justina Siroka-Pula and the government in Pristina have responded to the Specialist Chambers’ verdict in The Hague, which sentenced former president Hashim Thaci to 17 months in prison for obstruction of justice. The government issued its statement on November 17, and the president’s office followed on the morning of November 18. Both reactions point the same way: concern over the rights of the parties in the proceedings, and criticism of the court.

What did The Hague rule on Thaci and his associates?

Single Judge Christopher Gosnell found Thaci (58) guilty of obstructing official persons through joint action, violating the secrecy of proceedings and contempt of court. He was acquitted on one count of attempted obstruction and one count of contempt. Prosecutors had asked for six years in prison.

The court found that in 2023, at the detention facility in The Hague, he disclosed confidential information and the identities of six protected witnesses from the main trial to visitors, and used them to pass on instructions about how to testify. The evidence included audio recordings of the visits, papers printed on a printer at the detention center, and documents seized in searches in Kosovo.

In the same case, Baskim Smakaj and Fadilj Fazliju were each sentenced to 12 months and released, because they had already served that time in detention. Isni Kiljaj was acquitted. For Hajredin Kuci, the sources differ: N1, European Western Balkans and Radio KIM, in its text on Siroka-Pula, report a one-month suspended sentence with a one-year probation period, while Radio KIM, in its text on the government statement, writes of a six-month suspended sentence.

The sources also disagree on how the sentence will be served. N1 reports that the judge ordered the sentences from the two cases to be served consecutively, as prosecutors had requested. European Western Balkans writes that Thaci will serve this sentence only after the main war crimes trial ends, and only if that verdict is upheld on appeal. In that trial, Thaci was sentenced on September 16, not yet finally, to 25 years in prison.

What does the Kosovo government say?

The government’s statement began as follows:

“The independence of the judiciary and respect for court decisions are fundamental principles of the rule of law. However, that does not exclude the right and the responsibility to express concern about how judicial institutions function.”

It then reaffirmed its earlier position toward the court:

“The criticism and reservations we have consistently expressed toward the Specialist Chambers remain in force, especially regarding the transparency of proceedings, respect for the rights of the parties and the guarantee of fair trial standards.”

The government adds: “Trust in justice is built not only on the decisions that are made, but also on the way they are reached.” The statement closes by saying that justice “must not only be done, but must also be fair, transparent and credible.” It offers no separate assessment of Thaci’s guilt.

What did Justina Siroka-Pula say?

In a statement from her office, the president said that “the verdict of the Specialist Chambers raises concern regarding respect for the rights of the parties in the proceedings.” She added that “every institution of the Republic of Kosovo, including the Specialist Chambers, must act in accordance with the competences set out in the Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo.”

She also said that “the Republic of Kosovo remains committed to justice, the rule of law and respect for fundamental human rights and freedoms,” and made a request of the court: “We expect the Specialist Chambers to act in that spirit as well, and that all court proceedings and the right to appeal will be carried out in accordance with international fair trial standards.”

She stressed “that the contribution of the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) in the struggle for freedom and independence, as well as the sacrifice of the people of Kosovo, are part of Kosovo’s history and cannot be called into question by court proceedings.”

How did Thaci and his party react?

After the verdict was read, Thaci said, according to Pristina media present in the courtroom: “This is politics, not justice.” Acting Democratic Party of Kosovo leader Vljora Citaku called the verdict shameful and unacceptable, according to Radio Free Europe. The same outlet reports that Thaci had earlier announced an appeal against the war crimes verdict and is expected to challenge this one too. The verdict is a first-instance ruling.

What is the backdrop to the verdict?

The verdict comes after weeks of protests against the Specialist Chambers in Kosovo. On October 5, the Kosovo Assembly adopted in first reading, with 90 votes in favor and none against, amendments to the law on the Specialist Chambers that would limit the court’s mandate. Pristina’s international partners opposed them, and Siroka-Pula sent them back to the Assembly for reconsideration. The November 13 session was adjourned again after nearly 12 hours because of a lack of quorum.

On the same day the president spoke, the Specialist Chambers approved a humanitarian visit to Kosovo for Jakup Krasnici, who was sentenced to 25 years in prison, because his wife Sevdije’s health has worsened. It is his second visit since he was transferred to The Hague, and EULEX and Kosovo police have been deployed near his home.

We found no official reaction from Belgrade to the Thaci verdict in the sources we reviewed, and as of noon on November 18 we had not come across any statement from the Office for Kosovo and Metohija.

Podeli
Komentari…
Next storyKosovo Assembly Narrows Specialist Chambers JurisdictionMPs backed a Democratic Party of Kosovo proposal in first reading with 91 votes, as KLA veterans blocked the entrance outside and the Srpska Lista MPs stayed away.

From other sections

Most read today

  1. Serbian Parliament Constituted, All 250 Mandates Confirmed
  2. Lidija Vukicevic doused with yogurt outside parliament
  3. Stevandic re-elected Republika Srpska parliament speaker
  4. Cupic vs Radenovic for Serbian Parliament Speaker
  5. Serbia Presidential Election: Deadlines Through December 27

Komentari (0)

Ostavi komentar

Komentari prolaze kratku moderaciju. Lični napadi i govor mržnje se brišu.

Još nema komentara. Budi prvi i podeli mišljenje.