Chris Brown to Pay Housekeeper Maria Avila $9.5 Million
Maria Avila accepted a reduced award instead of a new trial. The dispute over the 2020 attack by Brown's dog Hades in Tarzana ends after five years.

Chris Brown must pay $9.5 million to his former housekeeper Maria Avila. Her attorney, Nancy Dumanian, confirmed in a filing with a Los Angeles court that her client accepted that amount, so there will be no new trial. The dispute dates back to 2021.
A Los Angeles jury awarded Avila $12.9 million in June 2026, which is $3.4 million more than she will now receive. Judge Huey P. Cotton of the Los Angeles County Superior Court found that figure “excessive.” A court order dated September 29 gave Avila a choice: accept $9.5 million, or have the amount of damages decided at a new trial. She chose the former.
What Did the Judge Find Insufficiently Proven?
Cotton explained that there was not enough evidence of more severe permanent nerve damage. Nor was there a basis for estimating damages for pain and suffering Avila might endure in the future. He did not question some of the consequences, however:
“There was evidence that she will continue to suffer serious emotional consequences, a sense of humiliation and shame, as well as other, less serious consequences, including some permanent pain caused by nerve damage,” the court’s ruling states.
Last week, Avila’s attorney asked the court to set the total award at $11 million. She argued that her client still has problems with her fingers and wrist because of a radial nerve injury.
Brown asked for a new trial in August. He argued that legal errors during the proceedings had affected the jury’s decision on the amount of damages. He singled out in particular the mention of his 2009 criminal conviction for assaulting his former girlfriend Rihanna.
The Tarzana Attack and Testimony at Trial
The attack took place on December 12, 2020, at Brown’s estate in Tarzana, California. Avila was attacked by the guard dog Hades, a Caucasian shepherd weighing about 90 kilograms. Her injuries included radial nerve damage, problems with her fingers and wrist, and wounds to her face. She filed her lawsuit in 2021 and originally sought $90 million.
On June 24, she told the jury: “I will never be the same again.” She said the dog attacked her as she went to empty a vacuum cleaner, and she showed the jury the injuries to her face and hands.
Brown acknowledged at trial that the housekeeper had been badly hurt:
“Her face was torn open, like a piece of skin had been ripped off. I know it sounds gruesome, but her skin was lifted. You could see an open wound and blood,” the singer said.
He added that he left the house before paramedics arrived, on the advice of his manager, and that he cited being a public figure as the reason. Asked why that affected his decision, he answered: “Because of the image that follows me and the way it is always used against me.”
Avila’s daughter, Jocelyn Espinoza, also testified. She recounted a call from her aunt Patricia right after the attack: “She was completely beside herself. She kept telling me: ‘Mom can’t breathe. She keeps losing consciousness. The ambulance still hasn’t arrived. Chris Brown ran away from the scene.’ I thought she wasn’t going to survive.”
Damages for Avila’s Sister as Well
The verdict also concerns Avila’s sister Patricia, who was working at the estate on the day of the attack. Brown and his company must pay her damages for emotional distress following the incident. The amount differs between sources: the magazine Novosti reports $885,000, while the American outlet Rolling Out writes of more than $850,000.
Her attorney, Michael C. Murphy Jr., said after the decision: “After more than five years of legal battle with Chris Brown, we are thrilled to have secured justice for our client Patricia. We are very happy for her and her family after everything they went through on that horrific day. It was an honor to represent her.”



