Giant Crocodiles Topped the Food Chain, Not Mammals
A University of Helsinki team analyzed bite marks on fossils between 10.5 and 16 million years old and concluded that giant crocodiles, not mammal predators, hunted the largest prey.

Giant crocodiles, not mammal predators, were the top hunters in tropical South America more than ten million years ago. That is the conclusion reached by scientists at the University of Helsinki, in a study published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. The evidence comes from bite and tooth marks predators left on the bones of large herbivores, found at sites in present-day Colombia.
South America looked different during the Miocene. Much of the continent was covered by a vast system of lakes and wetlands, known as proto-Amazonia, home to giant turtles and crocodiles. A whole range of predators hunted along its shores: anacondas, saber-toothed mammals, flightless birds of prey, and sebecids, land-dwelling relatives of crocodiles.
Oscar Wilson, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Helsinki, explains why mammal predators did not sit at the top of that food chain.
There was so much prey available that mammalian predators could not eat it all. Our new research shows that it was in fact crocodiles that were the most important predators in the region, especially when it comes to hunting large prey.
The largest predator of that era was Purussaurus neivensis, a relative of today’s caimans. It reached seven meters in length and weighed around 1,800 kilograms.
Who Was the Prey
Herbivores along the shores of that lake system were just as massive. Giant sloths lived there, along with glyptodonts, relatives of today’s armadillos, and several groups of hoofed mammals, including astrapotheres and toxodonts. The name astrapothere translates as “thunder beast.” Many of these herbivores weighed more than a ton, meaning Purussaurus hunted animals comparable to its own size.
The frequency of marks on their bones led the authors to a broader conclusion. If large prey so regularly ended up in a crocodile’s jaws, then Purussaurus may have influenced how many herbivores existed in that ecosystem in the first place.
Why Tooth Marks Are the Only Direct Evidence
The team worked with fossils already held in museum collections, without any new fieldwork. The specimens examined range between 10.5 and 16 million years old, placing them in the middle Miocene.
Bite and tooth marks on herbivore bones are the only kind of direct evidence of relationships between species from the distant past. Everything else, who hunted whom and how often, remains an indirect conclusion drawn from body structure and animal size. That is why paleontologists give these scars on bone a weight no other kind of find carries.
The frequency of marks likely made by Purussaurus suggests it was an important predator in these tropical ecosystems.
Wilson’s sentence carries a caveat that matters as much as the finding itself.
What This Does Not Prove
The marks are attributed to Purussaurus as the most likely source, not as a confirmed one. The study describes them as scars probably made by that crocodile, since a single bite fifteen million years old cannot be tied to one specific individual.
The impact on herbivore population numbers is likewise presented as a possibility the find suggests, not as a measured figure. The study offers a description of the relationship, not a number.
The material comes from sites in present-day Colombia and spans a range of five and a half million years. The picture the study paints applies to that ecosystem during that period, not to the whole continent or the entire Miocene. What the fossils show is that within the lake and wetland system that once covered northern South America, crocodiles, not mammals, were the ones most often hunting large prey.



