Srpske NovineSrpske Novine

Five EU States Block Cluster 3 for Serbia, Minister Warns

Minister Nemanja Starovic says Serbia remains blocked from opening Cluster 3 despite five positive recommendations from the European Commission, as at least five member states tie progress to the rule of law and sanctions on Russia.

Milan Stanković3 min read0
Podeli
The Berlaymont headquarters of the European Commission in Brussels with European Union flags on display
The European Commission headquarters in Brussels, where decisions on opening negotiating clusters with Serbia are made./ Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
In brief
  • Minister Nemanja Starovic said Serbia is still blocked from opening Cluster 3 despite five consecutive positive recommendations from the European Commission.
  • At least five member states are blocking the move: the Netherlands, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Sweden.
  • The reasons are the state of the rule of law and, for some countries, the fact that Serbia has not imposed sanctions on Russia.
  • Cluster 3 covers competitiveness and inclusive growth across eight chapters, and the stalemate is political because there is no unanimous backing from the states.

Nemanja Starovic, the minister for European integration, said on July 3 that Serbia is still blocked from opening Cluster 3 in its European Union accession talks, even though the European Commission has recommended opening that cluster in five successive reports. In his view, the obstacle is not technical, since Brussels has issued a positive expert assessment, but purely political, because at least five member states are withholding their consent. Opening a cluster requires the unanimous agreement of all twenty-seven members, so it takes only one capital saying no to bring the whole process to a halt.

The countries blocking the move are the Netherlands, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Sweden. Their reasons partly overlap and partly differ. The common denominator is the state of the rule of law in Serbia, above all the independence of the judiciary, the fight against corruption and media freedom. For some members, especially those in the north and northeast of the Union, an added and increasingly heavy factor is that Serbia has not aligned its foreign policy with the bloc and has not imposed sanctions on Russia. The combination of those two issues turns Cluster 3 into the point where Serbia’s European path stalls.

What does Cluster 3 actually cover?

Cluster 3 is titled competitiveness and inclusive growth and is one of the most substantial parts of the negotiating framework. It groups eight negotiating chapters that span areas from the information society and media, through taxation and economic policy, to education, social policy and enterprise. This is a cluster that directly touches citizens’ daily lives and business conditions, so freezing it is not just a symbolic delay on paper.

The stalemate is all the more sensitive because it comes despite a positive assessment from the Commission itself. When the bloc’s technical body says five times in a row that the conditions for opening are met, yet the cluster stays closed, it is clear that the decision has moved from the expert level to the political one. That cancels the usual logic of negotiations, in which met criteria lead to the next step, and introduces a new standard under which even a positive recommendation does not guarantee progress.

Is the stalemate technical or political?

The answer Starovic offers is unambiguous: the obstacle is political. That judgment matters because it changes the nature of the debate. If the problem were technical, the solution would lie in further reforms, new laws and meeting measurable conditions. Since the obstacle is political, the solution depends on the will of five capitals that want concrete movement where there has not been enough of it so far, in the judiciary, in the media space and in foreign-policy alignment.

The message from the government is that Serbia remains committed to the European path and that responsibility lies with the member states conditioning the process, not with Belgrade, which has secured five positive recommendations. The opposition, on the other hand, argues that it is precisely the state of the rule of law and the absence of reforms that keep Serbia standing still, and that the foreign members are citing problems that are domestic rather than invented. Both sides agree on one thing, however: that Cluster 3 has become the clearest gauge of how far Serbia’s European integration has entered a phase in which the fate of the talks is decided beyond expert reports.

Do you believe Serbia will persuade the five member states to lift their veto by the end of the year, or will Cluster 3 stay closed until its approach to the judiciary and Russia changes?

Podeli
Komentari…
Next storyBrussels Splits Billions, Serbia Risks Losing Its ShareThe European Commission is reallocating the six-billion-euro Western Balkans Growth Plan in July, while roughly 1.5 billion earmarked for Serbia stays frozen over stalled reforms.

From other sections

Most read today

  1. Greece vs Serbia: Zivkovic and Dragojevic Out in Volos
  2. Stevandic re-elected Republika Srpska parliament speaker
  3. Student List to Elect Assembly Speaker by Majority Vote
  4. Air Serbia Bars Montenegrin Fans From Larnaca Flight
  5. Kos regrets Oj Kosovo song at EU enlargement forum

Komentari (0)

Ostavi komentar

Komentari prolaze kratku moderaciju. Lični napadi i govor mržnje se brišu.

Još nema komentara. Budi prvi i podeli mišljenje.